We are now into the Autumn season and the Michaelmas term, which means an influx of new court judgments. This author was delighted to stumble upon the latest decision in the intriguing litigation between Secretary of State for Health and Others v Servier when browsing through the recent list of Chancery decisions ([2016] EWHC 366 (Ch)). This long running saga concerns the thorny intersection of patent rights and antitrust claims, and now - an added attraction in the form of the government's role in providing prescribing guidance to healthcare professionals, and making changes to the NHS drugs tariff for reimbursement.
![]() |
The IPKat was rather less enthused by the decision. |
Servier are the suppliers of the original, branded version of Perindopril, which was supplied in the UK under the brand name "Coversyl". Perindopril is an angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor ("ACE inhibitor") which is used in the treatment of hypertension and congestive heart failure. Patent EP 1 296 947 (the '947 Patent) was a patent for a particular crystalline form of Perindopril – the alpha crystalline form - which Servier applied for in 2001, and which was in 2007 held to be invalid for lack of novelty and obviousness in Les Laboratories Servier v Apotex Inc ([2007] EWHC 1538 (Pat), upheld by the Court of Appeal [2008] EWCA Civ 445.) In those proceedings it was held that one of Servier's pre-existing process patents, EP 0 308 341, led to the production of the alpha form as its inevitable result.
Following a decision of the European Commission, the Secretary of State for Health ("DoH") has brought a claim in the High Court of England & Wales alleging that Servier tortiuously interfered with the DoH's economic interests by unlawful means in that it procured, defended and enforced the '947 Patent. The DoH also alleges breach of Article 102 of the TFEU, on the basis that Servier was dominant on the market for the supply of Perindopril or for the supply of ACE inhibitors in the UK between 2011-2007, and that it abused its dominant position. Further, it claims an infringement of Article 101, on the basis that Servier concluded anti-competitive settlement agreements with various generic suppliers which precluded those companies from challenging the '947 patent, or from supplying generic Perindopril in the UK (i.e. 'pay for delay').
Similar legal proceedings have been issued by the Scottish, N Irish, and Welsh health authorities, and the cases have been linked and are proceeding in parallel.
Application to re-amend Defence
This decision concerned an application by Servier to re-amend its Defence, in a form which can be summarised as follows:
1. The Claimant failed to take reasonable steps to encourage switching from the prescription of Perindopril to the prescription of cheaper alternative ACE inhibitors in generic form (the "prescribing argument"). This: (a) results in a failure of the Claimant to mitigate its loss; (b) amounts to contributory negligence in relation to the tortious interference claims; and (c) broke the chain of causation/rendered any damage suffered by the Claimant too remote.The DoH opposed this amendment on the basis that it is 'not reasonable arguable'. The DoH's opposition was motivated by concerns that giving disclosure of all documents formerly held by Primary Care Trusts (predecessors to clinical commissioning groups) in relation to the prescribing argument, and addressing it in witness evidence and at trial would be extremely burdensome and expensive.
2. The Claimant failed to act expeditiously in moving Perindopril into category M (i.e. the 'generic' price category) of the NHS Drug Tariff. This proposed amendment was not challenged by the DoH.The Scottish, N Irish and Welsh health authorities did not oppose Servier's application to amend.
Analysis of the Court
It was common ground that the test for "not reasonably arguable" is the same as the summary judgment standard under Civil Procedure Rule Part 24, namely, whether the amendment has a real as opposed to fanciful prospect of success. The DoH submitted that there was a fundamental inconsistency between the prescribing argument and the nature of the causes of action. Claims under articles 101 and 102 are aimed at protecting consumers from market power being created artificially or exploited by producers in order to raise prices above competitive levels. It would be incompatible to reduce Servier's liability on the basis that the DoH (essentially the consumer) should never have purchased the product at the inflated price in the first place.
Henderson J analysed five separate arguments advanced by the DoH for saying that Servier's mitigation defence based on the prescribing argument had no real prospect of success (only the first will be analysed in this report, it being of particular interest). The court noted that the doctrine of mitigation cannot come into play before the relevant breach of contract has occurred. The issue then was whether the case against Servier involves: (a) allegations of a series of separate infringements of their rights occurring on each occasion when they purchased branded Perindopril; or (b) allegations of certain specific infringements of their rights at specific times which produced a series of losses stemming from those infringements on each occasion that Perindopril was subsequently bought. Ultimately, the issue turned on the form of the DoH's pleading. There was no clearly pleaded foundation for the proposition that each and every supply of Perindopril involved the accrual of a fresh cause of action. Instead, the claim was framed in the sense that the specific infringements alleged against Servier had the result that generic entry into the market was unlawfully delayed and the consequence that Servier was able to continue charging its normal price for branded Perindopril. The 'prescribing argument' was properly advanced as a failure to mitigate.
The DoH submitted that the prescribing argument could not provide a defence of contributory negligence, because the alleged negligence is not the effective cause of the loss, but merely the occasion for it. Henderson J noted that this was a highly fact-specific issue which was unlikely to be suitable for summary determination. It was reasonably arguable that the ongoing levels of purchase at Perindopril at a high price were caused in part by the DoH's conduct in failing to encourage switching to other ACE inhibitors. Similarly, it is possible that this alleged failure of the DoH amounted to a break in the chain of causation. In light of the above, Servier's "prescribing argument" defence in its various guises was allowed.
Comment
So far as this GuestKat is aware, this is the first occasion on which prescribing and reimbursement matters have been raised by way of defence in a claim made by public healthcare authorities against a pharmaceutical company. The 31 page judgment is a juicy one, and well worth a read for those interested in this area. It is worth remembering that the standard for introducing pleading amendments is a low hurdle, and it remains to be seen whether any of these defences will gain traction with the Court in due course.
makeup artist in gurgaon
BalasHapusmakeup academy in gurgaon
Do you know the best cure for Cancer is buy consuming cannabis and talking about consuuming cannbais, it is very disadvantageous to consume cannabis by smoking thats why Vapes have been introduced. The best place to get good vape carts if from
BalasHapusDank vapes
Dank Catridges
Dank official
danks vapes review
Dank vapes
what is dank
Dank vapes diamon og
Dank vapes full gram catridges
Dank vapes catridges
Dank vapes carts
Dank vape
NO PRESCRIPTION REQUIRED BUY PAINKILLERS ONLINE WITHOUT A PRESCRIPTION. WE OFFER A VALID PRESCRIPTION FOR YOUR ORDER
BalasHapusTHEN SHIP TOGETHER WITH YOUR PACKAGE.
buy alpha PHP online
buy flake cocaine online
cannadian pharmacy
pharmacy near me
buy pain killers online without prescription
sex enhancement pills for sale
buy steroid online
buy pain crystal meth online
where to buy ambien pills online
buy oxycodone online
biphetamine for sale
valium for sale online
buy ecstasy online australia
buy crystal mdma online
buy heroin online
buy percocet online
buy suboxone pills online
buy ketamine online
hydrocodone for sale online
salvia extract 40x
how to buy adderall online
This is my first time i visit here and I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially it's discussion, thank you.
BalasHapusKids Playground equipment
Commercial Playground equipment
I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious...
BalasHapusPreschool Playground equipment
nursery playground equipment
Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family.
BalasHapusCustom Buddy bench
Buddy bench
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
BalasHapusFriendship bench
Buddy bench for sale
I think that thanks for the valuabe information and insights you have so provided here.
BalasHapusdog park equipment
dog playground equipment
Thanks for sharing us.
BalasHapusSplash pad equipment
Splash pad equipment for sale
login joker123
BalasHapusginger dank vapes legit for sale
BalasHapusdank vapes pen for sale online
chemdawg dank vapes for sale
dank vapes cartridges for sale key lime pie
dank vapes thc cartridges for sale online
dank vapes for sale san diego
dank vapes- white widow for sale
dank vapes cartridges for sale
dank vapes for sale
buy dank vapes direct
dank vapes for sale near me
dank vapes for sale online
dank vapes thc cartridges for sale
tangie dank vapes cartridges for sale online
dank vapes for sale on instagram
dank vapes for sale "muncie," in
thc dank vapes cartridges for sale
dank vapes for sale ashtabula ohio
buy dank vapes reddit
KOLKATA CALL GIRL SERVICE
BalasHapusKOLKATA CALL GIRLS
CALL GIRL
Call GirlS
KOLKATA INDEPENDENT CALL GIRLS
KOLKATA INDEPENDENT CALL GIRL
ESCORT
ESCORTS
ESCORTS SERVICE
ESCORT SERVICE
INTERNATIONALSEX GUIDE KOLKATA
CALL GIRLS NEAR ME
CALL GIRLFRIEND RELATIONSHIP
ESCORT SERVICES
KOLKATA SEX
CALL GIRL IN KOLKATA
ESCORT SERVICE IN KOLKATA
GIRLS WHATAPP NUMBER
How Can You Earn With Social Media Sites
BalasHapusFinding Special Most Helpful SEO Businesses
BalasHapusCALL GIRL HOT PHOTO
BalasHapusKOLKATA CALL GIRL PICTURE
SONAGACHI GIRL PHOTO GALLERY
GIRLSPHOTOS
CALL GIRL BOOK ONLINE
KOLKATA BEAUTY
GIRLS NUMBER WHATSAPP
HIT GIRLS
WHATSAPP NAMBAR GIRL
TOP 10 SEXY GIRLS
ROYAL HOTEL KOLKATA
HOT MODELS LIST
SLUTS IN BANGALORE
HOTEL IN KOLKATA NEAR PARK STREET
KOLKATA 24X7 BANGLA
FEMALE ESCORT KOLKATA
THE MOST SEXIEST GIRL IN THE WORLD
GIRLFRIEND KA NUMBER
ESCORT WEBSITE
KOLKATA GIRLS WHATSAPP NO
HOT GRLS
SHOBHA THEATER
SEXY NAMES FOR GIRLS
ONLINE PROSTITUTE
DATING WOMAN IN KOLKATA
KOLKATA CALL GIRL MOBILE NO
SONAGACHI PHONE NUMBER
PATNA GIRL WHATSAPP NO
WHATSAPP NUMBERS GIRLS
CALL PROSTITUTES
HOTELS IN NEW TOWN KOLKATA
WHAT IS ESCORT
SEXIEST WOMEN PICS
WWW KALKATA SEX COM
HOTEL HOWRAH
NIGHT SEX GIRL
KOLKATA RED LIGHT AREA PICTURE
CALL GIRLS APP
I love the way you write and share your niche! Very interesting and different! Keep it coming!
BalasHapusAir Explore Pro Crack
Aimersoft Itube Studio Crack